When Marketing Has to Extract the Strategy
It’s a familiar moment: you join a company, step into a new project, or take on a consulting role, and quickly realize there is no real strategy.
There are goals, sure: "We want to grow faster," "We need leads," "We’re launching a new product." But these are outcomes, not plans. And the space between vision and execution is often filled with assumptions, opinions, or noise.
This isn’t a knock on the business. Most founders and operational leaders are deep in the work. They’re close to the product, the customers, the market. But they’re not always trained to translate that proximity into a coherent go-to-market or brand strategy.
That’s where marketing leadership steps in - not just to execute, but to extract. To ask the right questions. To pressure-test priorities. To define the path forward even when the map is missing.
In many roles, I’ve had to do exactly that. Sometimes the hard way. Sometimes quickly. Always with the understanding that clarity doesn’t emerge by accident, it has to be built.
Why This Happens
Let’s not pretend this only occurs in messy or mismanaged companies. This is more common than most will admit … especially in SMBs, founder-led businesses, or early-stage companies trying to scale. Strategy may exist in someone's head but hasn’t been clearly articulated. Sometimes the product team owns it. Other times, sales drives it. Or worse, the company is so focused on operational survival that nobody has had time to step back and define it at all. The result? A gap. Not from lack of effort, but from a lack of clarity. And when that gap exists, marketing becomes the default translator.
What It Looks Like in Practice
I’ve walked into organizations where everyone could articulate the product, but no one could articulate the story. Where KPIs were set, but no one could explain why they mattered. Where marketing was expected to "drive awareness" without knowing what made the brand different, or to whom.
In those moments, you don’t wait for clarity. You create it.
Here are some top line items that I like to look at first:
Start with the business model. What drives revenue? What constrains it? Follow the money.
Talk to sales and customer-facing teams. What are they hearing? Where’s the friction? What messages land? Which ones fall flat?
Look for pattern breaks. What’s different now? What’s changed about the market, your customers, or your offer?
Review existing data, but don’t stop there. Numbers tell part of the story. People fill in the rest. And sometimes, the absence of data says more than the presence of it.
Push for focus. Strategy isn’t about saying yes to everything. It’s about making the tradeoffs explicit.
Marketing as Translator and a Strategist
Too often, marketing is handed disconnected inputs: product sheets, leadership goals, investor pressure, sales targets, and expected to "make something happen." But real marketing strategy doesn’t just glue these things together.
It synthesizes them.
It asks: what do these inputs mean when viewed through the lens of the customer? What are we actually solving? And how do we position ourselves in a way that connects?
When done well, this isn’t just tactical alignment. It’s strategic translation.
A Simple Framework for Clarity
To extract strategy, marketers need more than instincts. They need a repeatable approach. Use a straightforward framework: Inputs → Synthesis → Alignment. It starts with gathering the right inputs: business goals, sales insights, market pressures, audience behaviors. Then synthesize; connecting dots to define positioning, value, and opportunity. Finally, align it internally with leadership, and externally through messaging and channel plans. This isn’t magic. It’s method. And it turns guesswork into strategy.
The Cost of Not Doing This
When marketing accepts unclear direction, it usually ends up doing one of three things:
Repeating what’s been done before, whether it worked or not
Chasing surface-level trends in lieu of actual insight
Delivering "activity" that fails to move meaningful metrics
None of these outcomes are good for the business. But they’re common. And often avoidable.
If someone doesn’t step up to extract the real strategy, the default is noise.
Our Perspective
This is where CLINTONSCOTT lives.
We step in not just to run campaigns or write messaging, but to find the throughline when no one else has time (or perspective) to do it. We ask the hard questions. We gather signals. We build alignment. And then we create marketing that actually works.
Because when strategy is unclear, marketing has a choice: wait and react, or lead and define. We choose the second one. Every time.
If this scenario feels familiar.
Feel free to share this with your social networks!